Results 1 to 2 of 2

Thread: Racism is wrong.

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Jun 2009

    Default Racism is wrong.

    Now, I've known for a long time that racists exist. I heard them talk on TV, I read what they say on a paper, I hear what they say at certain events...But for the first time last tuesday, someone wrote directly to me something extremely racist and antisemite. Not towards me. It was a client and it was against our opponents who have the bad taste to be arabs and jews.

    I opened the email and there it was, bold and in caps, "DIRTY JEW", "DIRTY ARAB".

    And I was shocked.

    I couldn't help but wonder if she thought I would maybe be receptive ? This message was just between me and her, in the special relation of trust and confidentiality between a lawyer and a client.

    Now, I've known for a long time that she is pratically insane, completely paranoid and alone. She's a poor and desperate lady. She has been racist before in front of me but it was more subtle. I explained I didn't want to hear stuff like that but I let it slide. She didn't stop though, and a part of me chose to ignore it because it was never to obvious.

    But now I have this dilemna that I never thought I'd have. If I decide to stop my mission, which I can legally do, I let her down. She can always find another lawyer but that won't be easy. She's just a poor, crazy woman, who happened to have been seriously wronged in one of her cases (it's all civil, nothing criminal).

    But if I go on defending her against these people that she despises, not only because of what they did but because of who they are, now that she has been so clear to me about her "opinion", it would be like approving of it somehow. Or at least like I don't care, that it's not so bad afterall.

    None of these solutions seems right.

    Last edited by Harleyquiiinn; 3 Hours Ago at 10:26 AM.

    All the Beautiful Things you do

    Respect my authoritah !

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Oct 2004


    So she's a horrible person. Many people are. Is that relevant to her case in any way? You say she's been badly wronged. Does she somehow not deserve justice just because she's horrible? It sounds like you should perhaps compartmentalize.

    What about free speech? You consider that an important right, I assume? The thing about free speech is it lets people say horrible things. And because free speech is important we have to defend their right to say horrible things. Dropping her as a client would, in a way, be punishing her for practising free speech. Okay I have no idea if France even guarantees a right to free speech. But still.

    You've also stated she's basically crazy. You need to ask yourself if she's even capable of better behaviour. Can she even understand that it is wrong to say these things?

    And finally, racism is a term often misused, I feel. I agree with the definition of racism that says actual discrimination needs to be involved, not just prejudice. Because, again, people really do have the right to hold hateful opinions if they wish. They do not, however, have the right to persecute or discriminate. It seems to me this woman is merely prejudiced and, while that is distasteful, do you really want to drop this client simply because she holds a different opinion to you? I could perhaps make an argument that you would actually be discriminating at that point.

    Obviously it doesn't matter to me which choice you actually make. I'm merely trying to help you make one and I got the feeling you'd like to keep her as a client but were struggling to justify it so I went that way with it. You could also consider giving her a final warning for her behaviour, letting her know any recurrence would result in you dropping her. Though again you have to ask yourself if she even CAN stop.

    Good luck deciding!
    Today a young man on acid realized that all matter is merely energy condensed to a slow vibration, that we are all one consciousness experiencing itself subjectively, there is no such thing as death, life is only a dream, and we are the imagination of ourselves. Bill Hicks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts