The Future Is Now

[KickHimWhenHe'sDown]

Any examples of this Sum 41 business?

I always thought Some Say and Wonderwall sounded really similar.
Some Say
Wonderwall

I'm sure there are more examples that others can point you to. I don't always notice similarities.

Sum 41 is a good example, actually. They've been doing it ever since Chuck too. Even moreso with Underclass Hero, even though they dialed it down a bit with Screaming Bloody Murder. When The Offspring's songs started sounding closer to other things, the first thing I thought was "uh oh, I hope they don't become another Sum 41". Ironic, considering Does This Look Infected takes a lot from The Offspring.

Maybe that's why DTLI? is my favorite album by them.

[0r4ng3]

Two I can think of off the top of my head: "The Bitter End" sounds like "Battery" by Metallica and "The Jester" sounds like "House Of Wolves" by My Chemical Romance. There are a few more, but those are the most notable. Don't get me wrong, I do like Sum 41, but I've noticed that they're not the most original.

[dff_punk]

I'd just like to add that Sum 41 always picked really great songs as their "inspiration".

[XYlophonetreeZ]

Ironic, considering Does This Look Infected takes a lot from The Offspring.

Yeah, I've always thought that record sounded a lot like the Offspring.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XjRb7PYu_Pk
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e2rjbVlUKkE

[Llamas]

Any examples of this Sum 41 business?

Two I can think of off the top of my head: "The Bitter End" sounds like "Battery" by Metallica and "The Jester" sounds like "House Of Wolves" by My Chemical Romance. There are a few more, but those are the most notable. Don't get me wrong, I do like Sum 41, but I've noticed that they're not the most original.

The biggest offender in my opinion is We're All To Blame vs SOAD's Chop Suey. Listen to the song structure and the choruses. I really don't think the Offspring rips people off this badly.

[GamerKT]

The biggest offender in my opinion is We're All To Blame vs SOAD's Chop Suey. Listen to the song structure and the choruses. I really don't think the Offspring rips people off this badly.

All of you guys must have bat ears. I really would never make any of these connections myself. I still feel like it's a stretch. Then again, most rock songs are verse-chorus-verse-bridge-chorus, so there's bound to be a bunch of similarities.

[Llamas]

All of you guys must have bat ears. I really would never make any of these connections myself. I still feel like it's a stretch. Then again, most rock songs are verse-chorus-verse-bridge-chorus, so there's bound to be a bunch of similarities.

To be fair, I was trained in music theory, and I took ear training classes when I was a music student. The two songs I mentioned are mostly similar because of how the songs go from a fast, 4/4 verse into a half-time chorus with very similar vocal rhythms in the chorus. The verses are not very similar, except in contrast with their respective choruses. And vocal parts going into the chorus... "And we're all to blame", vs. "I don't think you trust". Not to mention how the chorus is structured... Especially with that guitar riff being so similar.

Oh, and the first thing yelled in the Sum 41 song is almost the same rhythm used in Chop Suey. "Take everything left from me" is the same as "when angels deserve to die".

I still like We're All to Blame, though. It's a good song in itself, even if every time I hear it, I think of Chop Suey.

[NoGuessing]

The biggest offender in my opinion is We're All To Blame vs SOAD's Chop Suey. Listen to the song structure and the choruses. I really don't think the Offspring rips people off this badly.

Fuck me dead, now that is a rip off.

[Eskimo]

It's weird with Sum 41.

They had that...third album was it? Which was all pretty much blatantly Offspring-sounding. Then the next one was totally "spot the Metallica references".

And it didn't ever bother me. I don't even like the band, but I guess them copying other bands blatantly made them better than their "own sounding" stuff was anyway. That Offspring-esque disc of theirs was actually kind of fun.

On the flip side though, it pissed me off to no end on RAFRAG, with all the Green Day sounding stuff in the second half. Hypocrite is me.

[TheNooseIsFalling]

All of you guys must have bat ears. I really would never make any of these connections myself. I still feel like it's a stretch. Then again, most rock songs are verse-chorus-verse-bridge-chorus, so there's bound to be a bunch of similarities.

Try 'Grab the devil..." vs Metallica's The Four Horsemen. I never really noticed the System-similiarities until now but yeah, they are a lot alike