I don't like Robert Sheehan in misfits, think he's too pretty in that! But overall, yeah, I think all the people on my list are more 'normal' and more commonly associated with being attractive.
I'm trying to think of less 'pretty' men that I find attractive! Hmmm.... Dylan Moran, maybe. Although I think a lot of what I love about him is his humour and his accent. And I have a slight thing for Aidan Gillen in Love/Hate. I'm not every much into manly looking men for some reason.