I doubt many people will comment, considering how dead this place is and especially all sections besides GC.
But now that Burials has been out for a bit, wondering how people would rate AFI's catalog.
Sing the Sorrow 10/10
Black Sails in the Sunset 9.9/10
The Art of Drowning 9.8/10 (I love all three of these albums to death, but I have to say Sing the Sorrow's my favorite)
All Hallows EP 9.5/10
Crash Love 7.5/10
Very Proud of Ya/Shut Your Mouth and Open Your Eyes/Answer That and Stay Fashionable 6/10
Of course we have the trifecta of BSiS/AoD/StS (none of which have a single song I dislike), and All Hallows Eve is equally good besides being short - but Burials is up there. It's a fantastic album, and very unexpected. It's very dark, but less emo. And that drumming on I Hope You Suffer... I like every track on the album, but especially the first 5 and the last 1.
Crash Love is quite good, with some seriously stellar tracks like Torch Song, Beautiful Thieves, End Transmission, Okay I Feel Better Now, Medicate, I Am Trying Hard to be Here, and Fainting Spells (amazing song)... but it's brought down by its weaker songs like Darling I Want to Destroy You and Veronica Sawyer Smokes.
Their first three albums I like, but I get a little bored. It's just too much of the same, and not very creative. But good fun, that's for sure.
And DecemberUnderground is still a steaming pile of shit. It has a few good songs (Kill Caustic, Miss Murder, The Interview, Endlessly She Said) and a few okay ones (Love Like Winter, Affliction, Kiss and Control), but the rest are just trash. Basically half the album sucks. In fact, in most of the songs on the album I do like, I really only like the chorus and find the rest of the song boring.